Notifications
Clear all

Asset class inputs effect on Roth conversions

2 Posts
1 Users
0 Reactions
8 Views
(@redvudu)
Eminent Member
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 14
Topic starter  

I started my plan at the beginning of 2025. I am using the following asset classes using custom rates of return and standard deviations for 2026. I have it set for advanced portfolio managing mode 2. Do these values seem reasonable?

For 2025 I entered my existing asset allocation for my targets since I knew I would slowly balance my portfolio of the course of the year. I now have my account balanced to meet my long term allocation so I plan on updating the targets for 2026.

The first time I ran a test Roth conversion for my newly balanced portfolio the results were way different than I expected compared to 2025. I then made the listed changes to the rates of return and standard deviation and reran it. The results are completely different again.

I now see how much a change to the inputs can make the results change. How does everyone handle this? Do you update the inputs each year?

My real plan was to just fill my 22% tax bracket each year until my RMD's start. I am using the Roth conversion analysis as a high level check to see if my plan makes sense year to year or to see if I should further limit my conversion for IRMAA steps.

My rates of return are nominal and I used 3.5% for inflation and a 2% adder for healthcare costs.

I run the Monte Carlo with correlated rates on and off plus I run historical for a few different scenarios.

The Roth conversion calculator doesn't show

Rate of return

Cash
%
US Stocks
%
Bonds
%
US SCV
%
International SCV
%
International Stocks
%
3 month treasury bills
%

Standard deviation

Cash
%
US Stocks
%
Bonds
%
US SCV
%
International SCV
%
International Stocks
%
3 month treasury bills
%

 



   
ReplyQuote
(@redvudu)
Eminent Member
Joined: 9 months ago
Posts: 14
Topic starter  

my cut and paste did no work. Here are the values

Cash - ROR 3.42% - Std Dev 1.0%

US Stock - ROR 9.0% - Std Dev 14.6%

Bonds - ROR 4.5% - Std Dev 5.6%

US SCV - ROR 11.5% - Std Dev 31.6%

Int SCV - ROR 13.3% - Std Dev 14.7%

Int Stocks - ROR 7.75% - Std Dev 15.37%

90 day treasury - ROR 3.65% - Std Dev 3.06%



   
ReplyQuote
Share: